Tuesday, August 5, 2014

Admin

Are You A Fan Of Teachers Hitting The Students?

I went to a temple school this morning and taught 3 groups of kindergarten students for about 50 minutes each. I didn't encounter any serious difficulty to the first as well as the last group. Unfortunately, the noise the second group possessed was way over the top.

While I personally prefer to be alone in the classroom with no Thai assistant around, the second group destroyed my concept of being the person in authority. 

When the Thai teacher left, the little ones with melting smiles and playful nature transformed into something menacing. What happened was unfathomable chaos and destruction. They started kicking and beating each other, slapped each other with anything they're holding, and hopped from one place to another. 

I felt I was invisible in front of their eyes. I felt insignificant. I reluctantly admitted my failure of controlling them.

But when the Thai teacher came back, they showed so much respect. The deafening shouts of more than 30 students were gone in an instant. Their ears were back at me. The order was restored.

It's no longer a surprise that most teachers here (TH) are practicing corporal punishment. They deem it necessary. Therefore, it is expected. 

Read: A FEW REASONS WHY I PREFER TEACHING ADULTS



Teachers hit the students on the head, neck or the hand. They hit if students are talking. For being naughty. And for getting an answer wrong. The list is endless. And when they hit, they hit hard. 

At first I didn't understand fully why Thai teachers can become military generals who use their loud voices and quick hands as weapons. Last week in a different class, I saw a Thai teacher hit one of the students. When she was about to do it again I immediately looked away. The student's face turned red. He bowed his head, and when he looked up his focus was back.

I am not a fan of hitting students as it may have a negative effect on them. But I must admit though that it really works like a charm. One intimidating command and the seemingly unstoppable lions became domesticated cats.

Truly, I am no experienced teacher for kids. Perhaps my motivation was lacking. But you know what? I wish the Thai teacher who was in and out of the room to pay her friend next door a visit didn't leave. I wish she stayed. Because in times like that, it is better to have no preference.

2 comments

Write comments
John
AUTHOR
September 11, 2014 at 12:45 PM delete

It is indeed Victorian, James. In fact, I don't like it and it pains me seeing students getting the punishment. But whoa, it helped a lot earlier.

Reply
avatar
james bond
AUTHOR
September 11, 2014 at 12:45 PM delete

it's a victorian model of teaching.

Reply
avatar

Recent Posts

About the Author

Khon Philippine

I'm a full time travel and tourism lecturer at a university in the north who also loves blogging during my spare time. I blog about news particularly in Thailand, personal travel stories, and anything under the sun.